Recently a person going by R. McCullouch (the email address they provided had a different first though, hmm) sent me a supposed transcript of a chat with a magicJack customer service rep, but since it was copied and pasted it can't be proven accurate and not doctored.
In that transcript, he made claims of the device being physically defective and easily broken at the USB plug, as a ploy to sell more magicJacks. He can make the claim but there no way for him to prove that he or someone else in home did not abuse the ...
<< MORE >>That’s
the total actual cost billed to my credit card covering the next five years. (the only other expense you
could possible incur are calls made by you to numbers outside the US and Canada,
but that’s prepaid so no surprise bill if you don’t have any prepaid $ in your
account then you can only call US and Canada (you can look up their
international calling rates here http://www.magicjack.com/3/faq/
most are comparable to Vonage), so now I won’t be bill again until June 2013.
The
“phone company” is more expensive than Vonage and cost can vary greatly
depending on the services you choose I’m not going to break out multitudes of
price options, but without long distance charges it’s likely to cost close to
$2000.00 for the same time frame and services. Since I have Vonage for now, I’ll
show you what they billed me as a comparison to magicJack.
The monthly
bill when I first got Vonage
|
Residential
Premium Unlimited Plan for 0-(000)-000-0000 (29/Sep-28/Oct) |
$24.99 |
|
Regulatory
Recovery Fee |
$0.99 |
|
Emergency
911 Cost Recovery |
$0.99 |
|
Federal
Universal Service Fee |
$1.76 |
|
State
Telecommunications Sales Tax |
$1.51 |
|
Local
License Tax |
$0.54 |
|
Local
Telecommunications Sales Tax |
$0.54 |
|
State
911 Fee |
$0.20 |
|
|
$0.13 |
|
Total
Amount |
$31.65 |
Total for 5 years of
monthly billing: $1899.00
My bill when I switched to
Vonages annual plan (does not include certain taxes bill separately, for me
$0.20 per month ($2.4 per year) not billed until it reaches a total of $5.00)
|
Annual
Residential Premium Unlimited Plan (Oct 29,2007 - Oct 28,2008) |
$239.99 |
|
New
Rate Plan Activation Charge |
$0.00 |
|
Regulatory
Recovery Fee |
$11.88 |
|
Emergency
911 Cost Recovery |
$11.88 |
|
Federal
Universal Service Fee |
$17.49 |
|
State
Telecommunications Sales Tax |
$14.77 |
|
Local
License Tax |
$5.28 |
|
Local
Telecommunications Sales Tax |
$5.28 |
|
|
$1.32 |
|
Total
Amount |
$307.89 |
Total for 5 years of Annual
billing: $1551.45
Vonage also has
many monthly
billable services like virtual numbers and toll free numbers. Services
like magicJack: They have a “Softphone” as an add on for existing
customers (on your computer screen) additional $9.99 a month for 500
minutes or the V-Phone (a USB device similar in use to the magicJack
but I don't think you can plug a phone into it)
for $39.95 (shipping?) then the same monthly fee as other monthly
Vonage lines. Also here is Vonage’s international rates http://www.vonage.com/intrates.php?showAll=t#J
I know there are bundle phone
services including other VOIPs, One I was told is 15.95 a month before taxes
and fees. Over 5 years that would be $957.00, Now let’s add the taxes and fees Vonage’s were
70.30 per year, so I’m assuming it should be about the same, Now the total is $1308.50.
If your monthly bill is different just multiply the total monthly cost by 60 to
get the five year cost, and then compare it to $100.80 to see if it’s worth the
cost over magicJack.
More about Skype; I'm not going to do a full out price comparison as it’s not a real phone line,
I have the free
Skype and I think its a good supplement to magicJack and if you
want can buy service to make it more phone like for a monthly cost plus
other charges, the costs are close to but still more than magicJack
(Here’s a link to their prices http://skype.com/prices/). The question is do I need more from them than the free Skype? The answer: NO, magicJack is a real
phone line that has 911, can be a primary or sole phone line, it's a device small enough
to fit in my pocket, a real phone can be plugged into it and it can be used on
any computer with broadband access just by plugging it into the USB port. Where as Skype must
be down loaded to every computer you wish to use it on and is more of an
advance voice and video chat than phone, the best thing about Skype's phone service is the WiFi phone (not cheap thought), it has no 911
and Skype doesn’t expected it to be used as a sole phone service anyway. Here’s a quote from there website:
"No
emergency calls with Skype. Skype is not a replacement for your ordinary telephone
and can't be used for emergency calling."
I think that says all I need to know. Skype free is good, anything more is a waste of money when you can get unlimited magicJack for less.
So
for real (not Skype) phone service
which do you think is the better bargain for five years of
service $1300.00+, 1500.00+, $2000.00+ or $100.80. Let's put that in a
different perspective for less that the cheapest Vonage unlimited
service for five years I could get 15
magicJacks phone numbers with five years of service. Which leads me to ask do you
think magicJack has 93.4% less service than Vonage, because that about
how much more Vonage's best would cost. I just doesn't make sense
to pay that much more for so little a difference in service.